Hey Joseph,
When I went, I fished with nightcrawlers from the damn, it's a short walk down the path, through the camp grounds, and I believe its accessible all night. We got some pretty large sunnies, but nothing else. We also took a ride down the street, there are a lot of areas of areas were you can pull off the road and fish, some areas seem to be more heavily fished. I would definately suggest taking a ride and exploring the area while trying to find quite areas to fish!
Good Luck!!